• 1 to 4.5 pound live or cooked lobsters, freshly dug steamers, or specials like mussels.
  • Lobster rolls, fried and grilled baskets of haddock, scallops, shrimp, salmon and fried clams.
  • Burgers, dogs, tenders and other non-seafood items.
  • Annabelle’s in the Ice Cream Shack.
  • We don’t serve alcohol, so bring a cooler with your choice of beer and wine.


Fresh Caught Hard Shell Lobster

Our lobsters are supplied by local lobstermen. The waters in our area are said to be some of the coldest and deepest on the coast of Maine. Ideal conditions for great lobster. Cooked lobsters are prepared in salt water.

Fresh Caught Soft Shell Lobster

Known as “shedders” they’re very sweet, and easy to eat. In most cases you can just tear the shells apart without need of any tools. They do, however, tend to have less meat in the claws. So, if you’re a big “claw meat person”, you may want to stick with hard shells. Cooked Lobsters are prepared in salt water.

Fresh Local Dug Steamer Clams

Fresh Local Mussels

When available

Styrofoam Cooler

$6.00 – $12.00
Keep your lobsters cool
Bring your own cooler! Spend your money on bigger lobsters.

Gel Packs

$1.00 – $2.00
Less Messy than Ice

Bag of Ice



All sandwiches come with chips, make it a “basket” with fries for $1.00 or onion rings for $2.50
All baskets come with fries, sub onion rings for $2.50

best maine lobster rollLobster Roll

Freshest in Maine! We pick our own lobster meat daily, add just a touch of mayonnaise and serve it on a buttered, grilled hot dog bun with lettuce.

The “Big Boy” Lobster Roll

When you can’t get enough, make it a Big Boy! We stuff twice the amount of lobster meat into a homemade potato roll for twice the fun!

Crab Roll

Crabmeat dressed with mayo and served on a grilled burger bun with lettuce.

Jenny Special Sandwich

Two great tastes that go great together! We fill a sandwich bun with a fresh piece of grilled haddock and top it with our homemade crab cake. Served with lettuce and your choice of sauce. May we suggest the Cilantro Mayonaise? A Five Islands favorite!

Somewhat Famous Crab Cake Sandwich

Two of ’em, all crab, no breadcrumb filler.

Grilled or Fried Haddock Sandwich

Grilled with just a touch of fresh squeezed lime or hand breaded with crumbs.

Grilled Salmon Sandwich

Great with Mustard Dill Sauce!

Fried Clam Basket

“Best in Maine” – Down East Magazine

Fried Scallop Basket

Fried Shrimp Basket

Sadly, Maine shrimp is not available in the 2015 season due to the limits imposed on the fishermen. We are choosing not to carry an imported (and in our opinion, inferior) product in support of the local fishing economy.

Fish & Chips

Made with Fresh Haddock

Salmon Fish & Chips


All Beef Burger

Add cheese, tomatoes, lettuce, onions, pickles and condiments. Add them all for “the works”.
All Beef Burger – Double
It is HUGE!

Five Island’s Steak and Cheese

Local favorite

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

Chicken Tender Basket

Ask for Honey Mustard, Barbeque or Sweet and Sour Sauce

Grilled Cheese

Plain and Simple

All Natural Casing Hot Dog


  • Haddock Chowder
  • Lobster Stew
  • When available
  • Corn on the Cob
  • At the Lobster Building
  • Salt water boiled with the lobsters
  • Red Potatoes
  • At the Lobster Building
  • Salt water boiled with the lobsters
  • Homemade Onion Rings
  • A huge serving, made fresh everyday
  • French Fries
  • Coleslaw
  • Cilantro Mayo, Mustard Dill, Tartar Sauce with Fresh Dill
  • Homemade and Wicked Good


A wide variety of flavors to choose from

  • Small Cone/Cup: $2.00
  • Medium Cone/Cup: $3.00
  • Large Cone/Cup: $4.00
  • Fresh Packed Pint: $6.00


  • Adult T’Shirts: $20.00
  • Kid T’Shirts:$15.00
  • Kid’s Hooded Sweatshirts: $30.00
  • Adult Hats: $15.00
  • Hooded Sweatshirts: $40.00


We feature Maine Made Soda including Maine Root, Eli’s and Stewart’s.